A million men died — and it wasn’t in World War One

A cynic could play cliché bingo in Britain today. “Ultimate sacrifice”, “pals’ battalion”, “over the top”, “the mud”, “No Man’s Land”, “over by Christmas”, “lions led by donkeys”, “four years of trench warfare.” We are treating 100 years’ tick tock like a sentimentalist Victorian treated the deserving poor. It’s like one of those signs as you drive into Hardy’s Wessex or Bronte’s Yorkshire… “Welcome to Great War Country!” Not looking forward to Christmas when they will trot out the ‘…we clambered out of our trenches to play football with the Germans, right there in No Man’s Land’ cliché on every channel and in every newspaper.

As armies had a policy of shooting at dawn those who signed on but changed their minds, there was not really much conspicuous heroism around — despite the garbage that will be spouted on radio, TV and from pulpits today in that special timbre of voice set aside for public grief. I bet, for the soldiers of World War One, it was mostly just a fond wish that the other bloke got his, not you.

There is a trend  in asymmetric warfare. You count your dead in valuable tens and theirs in meaningless thousands. It was true against the Zulus in 1879 as it was last month in Gaza. So when our tens turn out to be remembered but unknowable millions of ‘our brave boys’ (or scared men more like), over a long four years, then we do not know how to ratchet up our mawkish faux grief. Only the old have personal recollection of a soldier granddad who survived the war. For them and only them can there be genuine sadness still. For the rest of us this war should just join all the other wars. Maybe this is the day to remember that not only was World War One not the war to end all wars, it was not shockingly or outrageously different from those that came before.

Shields Gazette  8 Sept 1870: Click to read

Shields Gazette 8 Sept 1870: Click to read

Here’s a running total of the dead and wounded in battles – that’s battle, not wars – since Bannockburn, but this list only goes up to 1904.


And finally just to show how fluid were the alliances in Western and middle Europe during the 19th and 20th centuries, this little squib exploded into view from from the Western Daily Press dated Nov 3 1871. Oh, the irony!:-


This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to A million men died — and it wasn’t in World War One

  1. According to studies most humans find killing humans repugnant–even during war. We really have to train men to kill.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s